Trent Green: O.K. Trent is just O.K. There is nothing wrong with being O.K. Except you must have a very good team around you. Put Trent in New England and he could take you to the playoffs, put Trent in Miami and you're not going anywhere. He's just not the kind of QB that makes everyone around him better. I give Trent A SEVEN out of ten.

Tony Romo: He's good, he gets it. I think he just needs more experience. He just doesn't have enough games under his belt to recognize what those tricky defenses are going to do next. I think he'll be good for many years to come. So I give Tony An EIGHT out of ten.

Matt Hasselbeck: I don't know whats wrong here. He has skill, desire,talent and a good organization behind him. So why doesn't it happen for Matt? Someone has to loose. I give Matt an EIGHT out of ten.

Brett Favre: What can you say, the guy gets things done. He makes unbelievable plays. He's been playing for a long time, and his team wins allot. You wouldn't want him to train his successor. Because you wouldn't want someone else to take the chances he takes. Sometimes this aggressive play causes mistakes, but you can't argue with his success. So I give Brett because of his career, a TEN out of ten.

Derrik Anderson: His receivers make him look better than he is. I'm not saying he doesn't have talent, but if he wasn't throwing to some of the best receivers in the league (Kellen Winslow Jr., Joe Jurevicius, and Braylon Edwards) I don't know if he'd be a starter yet. Seriously have you seen Kellen Winslow Jr. play, he might not be the greatest all around TE yet, but he has hands like Jerry Rice. So I give Derrik a SIX out of ten.

Big Ben Rothlesberger: O.K. there is no secret to what Pittsburgh does on offense. Run the ball.
Run the ball effectively and when the other team forgets you have a passing game on third and short pass the ball down field. But every once in a while Pittsburgh forgets they are a running team & abandons the run and goes to the pass. When a defense knows they are going to pass they can stop them. But still they can't be stopped all the time because Ben is big. So I give Ben a SEVEN out of ten.

Donovan McNabb, Please this guy wasn't wanted in Philly from draft day on. If he wants to resurrect his career he should move on. I think he can play good, but he tries to hard, forgets there are ten other guys on the field, and plays injured, when he should be sitting on the bench nursing his injuries. So Donovan gets a SEVEN out of ten.

Perhaps I'll just discuss QBs for now.
A quarter back that just wont go away... Vinny Testaverde: The guys played along time, everyone in the league seems to like him. He's thrown a ton of interceptions. and I think if you could look at what QB has cost his team more wins it would be Vinny. So on a scale of one to ten, Vinny gets a FOUR.

Tom Brady: He's good, one of the best. But truth be told I don't think there is a weak position on the team. How can they loose? So I give Tommy Boy A TEN out of ten.

All right I'll get this started. Eli Manning: To me Eli is playing above his head. He wishes he was as good as his brother. And besides I just can't forgive him for making a mockery of the draft. So I'll give Eli a SIX out of ten.